Start here · five minutes

The case, step by step.

Six steps. No jargon. Every step links to the evidence, so you never have to take our word for it.

“The dog did nothing in the night-time.”
“That was the curious incident,” remarked Sherlock Holmes.

Arthur Conan Doyle, “Silver Blaze” (1893)
  1. 01

    The question

    Did William Shakspere of Stratford write The Works of Shakespeare? Not whether he existed, not whether he was an actor or a shareholder in a theater company. Did he write them, substantially and repeatedly?

  2. 02

    The test

    Take the twenty-four writers of the same age that the researcher Diana Price compared him with. Ask each one the same question: does an independent record from his own lifetime connect the man to literary work? Then ask it of Shakspere, in the same words.

    The standard, word for word →
  3. 03

    The result

    All twenty-four close their Authorship Chains.* Shakspere's Authorship Chain does not. His name is on title pages during his life; no independent record from his lifetime survives to put the pen in his hand.

    * Three of them, Beaumont, Kyd and Webster, close contingently.

    See all 25 Authorship Chains →
  4. 04

    What we grant

    No spelling games. For the argument, the book grants that Shakspere of Stratford is the Shakespeare named on the title pages, praised by Meres and presented in the Folio. His lifetime credit counts in his favor. The grant settles whom the evidence concerns. It cannot supply the missing link.

    The identity grant →
  5. 05

    What the defense says

    The orthodox case rests on strong lifetime attribution (the dedications, Meres, Davies) and on testimony after his death (Jonson, the First Folio, the Stratford monument). The book grants all of it its full force. The lifetime sources attach the name to The Works but never independently join it to The Man. The later ones can strengthen a lifetime link. They cannot create one.

    Watch for what the book calls the Stratfordian leap: the attribution is assumed, The Works are read for a life, and that life is then offered as proof of the attribution. The premise returns as the proof.

    Every objection, cross-examined →
  6. 06

    What the book does not claim

    It does not name another author. It does not claim proof beyond all doubt: within its specified test, the Stratford attribution fails. The twenty-four are a selected group, not a sample of every writer who ever lived. Those limits are stated up front, because a case that hides its limits deserves no trust.

    What the book does go on to argue, in Part III, holds only once the rejection is granted. The record shows The Man lending, brokering and holding plays as property: a go-between, not a writer. Of the accounts of how the credit reached his name, the book finds that concealment explains the most. It offers that as its best explanation, not as an established fact.

Your move. Break the test, or read the whole case.