Questions & answers

Did Shakespeare write Shakespeare?

Plain answers to the questions people ask first, from the doubtful and the skeptical alike. Each one links to the evidence behind it.

The question

Did Shakespeare write Shakespeare?

This book's answer, within its stated test: the claim that William Shakspere of Stratford was the substantial, recurring author of The Works fails. Twenty-four writers of his age each have an independent record from their own lifetime connecting them to literary work. He does not.

That is a conclusion about the evidence, reached by a method you can check. It is not a claim of certainty about history.

The case in five minutes →

What is the Shakespeare authorship question?

The debate over whether William Shakspere of Stratford-upon-Avon wrote the plays and poems published under the name William Shakespeare. Mainstream scholarship accepts that he did. Doubters argue that the documentary record does not support it. This book takes the documentary side of that argument and tests it.

Why does it matter who wrote the plays?

Because a biography built on the wrong man misreads The Works, and because a claim this large should rest on evidence rather than habit. The plays lose nothing. The question is whether the story told about their author is true.

Wasn't Shakespeare famous in his own lifetime?

The name was. The book grants that the name appeared on title pages and was praised while he lived; Meres listed the plays in 1598. What the record does not show is The Man connected to the writing by anything independent of that name.

The identity grant →

The test

What is an Authorship Chain?

A chain with two ends. On one side, a recoverable historical individual: a real person traceable in the records of his life. On the other, a recoverable authorial identity: the author known from his works. The Authorship Chain closes only when an independent connection joins them: a lifetime record, personal and discriminating, that does not depend on the attribution being tested.

All 25 Authorship Chains →

Why only records from his lifetime?

Because a connection that first appears after death cannot be checked against the life it describes. Later testimony is weighed for what it shows its witness knew, and it can strengthen a lifetime Authorship Chain, but it cannot create one. The same rule is applied to all twenty-five writers.

What is an independent connection?

A lifetime record connecting a recoverable historical individual to literary activity. It must be personal and discriminating, not impersonal or posthumous, and it must make the connection independently, not depend on the attribution being tested.

A title page reading “by William Shakespeare” is the attribution itself. It cannot also be the proof of it.

The definition, term by term →

Why these twenty-four writers?

They are the writers the researcher Diana Price compared with Shakespeare in 2001. Price is a doubter, and critics say so. The book uses her group because it was published years before this book, fixed in advance, and open for anyone to check; the test applied to it is the book's own. They are a selected group, not a sample of every writer who ever lived, and the book says so.

Method →

What does “contingent” mean?

A closure whose pathway is thin or qualified but still meets the standard. Three of the twenty-four, Beaumont, Kyd and Webster, close contingently. The site draws their Authorship Chains with dashed lines so you can see it.

Isn't absence of evidence not evidence of absence?

On its own, no, and the book does not argue from absence alone. It argues from a pattern: the same search, run on twenty-four contemporaries, finds what it is looking for every time. An absence counts only where the evidence should have been made, kept and found, and the book argues that case step by step. When a method succeeds twenty-four times and fails once, the failure needs explaining.

What would change the result?

The book says so in advance: a qualifying record from his lifetime connecting him to literary work. If the Hand D pages in the manuscript of Sir Thomas More are his, the minimum finding falls, and the book says that too.

Prove me wrong →

The objections

Isn't a thin record normal for the period?

That is the strongest objection, and the comparison is built to meet it. Records were lost for every writer of the age, not only for him. Comparing him with twenty-four contemporaries holds the period and its archives as level as a comparison can. The question is why the same losses left their Authorship Chains intact and his broken.

Gate G4: the lost papers →

What is “the Stratfordian leap”?

The book's name for a circular move. The attribution is accepted first; knowledge and experience are then read out of The Works and assigned to The Stratford Man; and the resulting biography is presented as confirmation of his authorship. The premise returns as the proof. Not every argument for Stratford makes this move: complementary sources can establish a connection together. The difference is between evidence that independently identifies the writer and an identification supplied in advance.

The case in five minutes →

Why do you spell it “Shakspere”?

Because that is how the records of his own life spell him: “Shakspere” at his baptism in 1564, at his children's baptisms and at his burial in 1616; “Shagspere” and “Shaxpere” at his marriage in 1582. These are civic and parish records of The Man, not literary records of The Author. Counted in those non-authorial records alone, the Stratford parish register spells the family name “Shakspere” in 13 of 19 entries (1562–1616), and none of his six surviving signatures, all on legal documents, begins “Shake”. Using his records' name keeps the recoverable historical individual distinct from the recoverable authorial identity, which the test needs.

The records, entry by entry →

Isn't his name on the title pages enough?

The book grants the attribution in full: the name on the title pages, Meres's list, the Folio. That is the claim being tested. The test asks for something beyond it, a record from his life that independently connects The Man to The Works. Every other writer in the comparison has one.

The identity grant →

Doesn't the First Folio settle it?

The First Folio was published in 1623, seven years after his death. Its tributes are real and they count. But testimony after death can strengthen a lifetime link to the work. It cannot create one.

Why the lifetime rule →

What about Ben Jonson?

“Sweet Swan of Avon” is praise from a man who knew him, printed in the Folio in 1623. The book weighs it, along with Jonson's other remarks. The question is whether praise printed after his death can do the work of a lifetime record. It cannot.

Jonson, cross-examined →

Isn't this just snobbery?

No. The test never asks about birth, schooling or class. It asks one thing of every writer: a record. A glover's son who left one would pass. A nobleman who left none would fail.

Don't nearly all scholars disagree?

Most do. Consensus is a reason to take a claim seriously, not a substitute for evidence. The test is public so that any scholar can show exactly where it goes wrong.

Show where it goes wrong →

The book and the author

So who wrote the plays?

The book names no one. Its argument concerns the evidence for the Stratford attribution, and it does not depend on any alternative candidate. A failed attribution is a finding in its own right.

Why the book names no one →

Why is the author anonymous?

So that the argument is judged on its evidence alone.

Who is Baxter Isaac Grey? →

Where can I get the book?

Something Rotten in Stratford is forthcoming from Cambridge Scholars Publishing. Sign up to hear the day it is out.

Get notified when it's out →

How can I check the evidence?

This site sets out the test, the definition and the finding. The book gives the full case record for every Authorship Chain, and every chain on this site gives its archive references. The Research Packet sets out the whole test so it can be repeated; anyone can download it free, with no sign-up.

The Research Packet →

How do I challenge it?

Name a gate, a definition, a document or an Authorship Chain; say what your evidence changes; cite a source anyone can check. The strongest challenges are answered in a monthly public log, and any that change a finding are reported at the top of the page.

Prove me wrong →

A question we have not answered? Ask it, or try to break the test.