Cross-examination
But what about Howes, 1615?
- The claim
In 1615 the chronicler Edmund Howes listed “M. Willi. Shakespeare gentleman” among “our moderne, and present excellent Poets”, a list he says he ranked by social standing and gave “in my owne knowledge”. A poet called a gentleman, and only the Stratford man had arms: the two must be one.
- The short answer
Howes repeats the attribution; he does not ground it. He names no work, no place and no family, so nothing on his page ties the name to Stratford. His “owne knowledge” vouches that these poets flourished in the Queen's reign, not that he knew any of them or knew who composed what: a chronicler's roll of public reputations, not a personal reference. And “gentleman” proves less than it seems. Howes extends the same style to other writers on the list who held no grant of arms, so on his page it reads as a courtesy to a respected writer, not as a pointer to the 1596 Stratford grant.
- The full cross-examination
The sources and the full answer are in the Research Packet, Annex B.
Request the Research Packet