Cover of Something Rotten in Stratford by Baxter Isaac Grey: a line portrait whose outline unravels into a red thread

The book · Coming soon

One standard of evidence. Twenty-five writers of the same age. Guess which one fails it.

SOMETHING ROTTEN IN STRATFORD

Evidence, Absence, Method, and Moving Beyond Myth

New to this? Start here: the case in five minutes →

Exhibit A · The Authorship Chain

Twenty-four Authorship Chains close. One does not.

On one side, a real man recoverable from the records. On the other, an author recoverable from his works. The question: does an independent lifetime record connect the two?

Independent connection: a lifetime record connecting a recoverable historical individual to literary activity.

It must be personal and discriminating, not impersonal or posthumous, and it must make the connection independently, not depend on the attribution being tested. The full definition →

  1. Ben JonsonClosed
  2. Thomas NasheClosed
  3. Philip MassingerClosed
  4. Gabriel HarveyClosed
  5. Edmund SpenserClosed
  6. Samuel DanielClosed
  7. George PeeleClosed
  8. Michael DraytonClosed
  9. George ChapmanClosed
  10. William DrummondClosed
  11. Anthony MundayClosed
  12. John MarstonClosed
  13. Thomas MiddletonClosed
  14. John LylyClosed
  15. Thomas HeywoodClosed
  16. Thomas LodgeClosed
  17. Robert GreeneClosed
  18. Thomas DekkerClosed
  19. Thomas WatsonClosed
  20. Christopher MarloweClosed
  21. Francis BeaumontClosed
  22. John FletcherClosed
  23. Thomas KydClosed
  24. John WebsterClosed
  25. Shakspere of StratfordIndependently unclosed

Price's twenty-four, tested on one standard: all twenty-four close. Shakspere: independently unclosed.

Every Authorship Chain in detail →
The identity grant Even when we grant that Shakspere is Shakespeare, his Authorship Chain still breaks. Here's why → Why we write “Shakspere”: the name in his own records →

Something is rotten in Stratford

The attribution claims more than its evidence can warrant.

For four centuries it has been taught as fact and defended as faith. His name was on the title pages. Not one independent record from his lifetime survives putting the pen in his hand.

No myth ends by mere debate. It ends when it is formally falsified: when one standard of proof is applied evenly to the historical record, and the myth fails it.

This book does just this. Within its stated test, the Stratford attribution fails.

The post-Stratfordian era, moving beyond Stratfordian myth, begins with a method.

Follow every Authorship Chain in the book.